Here is a quote from a recent interview with Michael Horton in Christianity Today (Nov. 2009, p. 49). Mr. Horton is a professor at Westminster Seminary in Escondido, CA, and the author of Christless Christianity.
“You also say it’s [the Gospel] not ‘a personal relationship with God’ or ‘making Jesus your Lord and Savior.’ What do you mean?
I realize that those are deeply held, personal convictions among many evangelicals. But everyone has a personal relationship with God. You start with Genesis and work your way to the Book of Revelation–everyone has a relationship with God. In Romans 1-3, Paul says Gentiles have a relationship with God, even when they are engaging in idolatry. The question is whether the relationship is with a father, who has justified and adopted his heirs, or with a judge.
The phrase ‘making Jesus Lord and Savior’ does not appear anywhere in Scripture (any more than does ‘personal relationship’). It assumes we are the ones who make God something. It is hard to imagine a Jew saying he made God his liberator and Lord in the Exodus. No. God made the Israelites the recipients of his saving and lordly work. So we don’t make God anything; it is he who makes us his people. The Good News is not that Jesus has made it possible for you to make him Lord and Savior. The Good News is that he has actually saved and liberated you, and that he is your Savior.”
There is much confusion about the salvation today because we have adopted these and other unbiblical phrases to represent the Gospel. The gospel is the death, burial, and resurrection of Christ applied by faith to the hopelessly lost repentant sinner through the mercy and grace of God.